Artificial Intelligence has swiftly become the darling of modern innovation—reshaping industries, redefining productivity, and inspiring entirely new business models. But in the rush to embrace its promise, organizations are confronting an urgent, often overlooked risk: Shadow AI.
In a recent conversation, a senior executive at a major software company unpacked the hidden implications of unchecked AI adoption in the enterprise. From their vantage point—advising Fortune 500 CISOs and CTOs on security strategy—the threat is clear: Shadow AI is the new Shadow IT, and its impact may be even more disruptive.
What Is Shadow AI?
Much like Shadow IT, Shadow AI refers to the unsanctioned use of artificial intelligence tools within an organization. Employees, driven by curiosity or productivity goals, begin experimenting with AI applications—often without the knowledge or oversight of IT or security teams. Whether it's using generative tools like ChatGPT to draft emails or uploading sensitive data to AI-powered analytics engines, these interactions create significant blind spots.
“It’s not that AI gives people access they didn’t already have,” the executive explained. “It’s that it exposes the access they already had—data they never realized was reachable. That gets risky very quickly.”
Think HR files. Intellectual property. Regulatory data. Financial records. When employees feed these into AI systems with unclear data governance or opaque model architectures, the result can be catastrophic.
AI and Data Governance: Security Gaps You Can’t Ignore
Shadow AI has exposed the cracks in many organizations’ foundations, particularly around identity and access management (IAM) and data security.
"We’re still talking about DLP after 25 years," the executive said, noting how many organizations implemented only 30–40% of their data loss prevention capabilities and then stalled. Now, with AI reasoning over massive datasets in seconds, that oversight isn’t just inefficient—it’s dangerous.
And it's not just internal risks. Threat actors are leveraging AI, too. The executive highlighted how attackers now use AI to supercharge phishing, social engineering, and data analysis. “What used to take them weeks or months, now takes minutes. That accelerates the attack lifecycle dramatically.”
AI Governance Risks: Why Security Can’t Be an Afterthought
Despite growing awareness, many organizations are still racing ahead with AI deployments—often without involving security teams early enough. "We threw security by design out the window for AI," the executive observed. “We're repeating the same mistakes of the past—tacking security on at the end instead of baking it in from the start.”
From the boardroom to the engineering team, everyone wants AI, but few are asking the hard questions:
- What data can we feed into these models?
- Have we anonymized sensitive content?
- Are these systems hosted, or are they local?
- What’s our plan for data retention or deletion?
Without clear answers, the enterprise becomes vulnerable—not just to data exposure, but to noncompliance with regulations like GDPR or the EU AI Act.
The Rise of AI Agents… and Shadow Agents
Looking ahead, the risks compound further with the evolution of AI agents—autonomous systems that act on behalf of humans.
We’re already seeing this with virtual assistants and automated bots. But as agents become more capable, they'll require governance models equivalent to those used for human users: IAM, activity logging, behavioral constraints, and revocation mechanisms.
The risk? Shadow agents—unauthorized or rogue AI processes operating without visibility or control. “It’s not just about bad actors,” the executive warned. “What happens when an agent decides the guardrails are too restrictive and tries to bypass them?”
How CISOs Can Respond to the Rise of Shadow AI
So, how can security leaders respond?
“Back to the basics,” the executive emphasized. The fundamentals haven’t changed:
- Start with a strong asset inventory: Know your data, devices, and identities.
- Double down on identity-first security: Every human and non-human identity needs clear, enforceable permissions.
- Focus on data security posture management: What data do you have, where is it, and who can access it?
- Maintain zero trust principles, but balance them with zero-friction policies to keep users productive.
Security doesn’t need to be a roadblock. When done right, it's invisible—built into workflows, enabling safe innovation.
Final Thoughts: From Risk to Resilience
Shadow AI isn’t just a technical problem. It’s a governance problem, a cultural challenge, and a test of how quickly security can adapt to innovation.
CISOs must evolve from being the “department of no” to the department of know, bringing clarity, context, and guardrails to AI adoption. It’s about guiding the business to move fast safely, not halting progress out of fear.
In the words of our guest: “We can absolutely make security fun. The best security is the kind you don’t even see—but it’s there, helping you do your job better.”
In the age of AI, that's not just a goal. It’s a necessity.
See how Segura® helps security teams control Shadow AI, enforce identity-first governance, and protect sensitive data across hybrid environments. Explore our platform →
Joseph Carson is a globally recognized cybersecurity expert with over 30 years of experience in enterprise security and infrastructure. He is the author of Cybersecurity for Dummies and host of the Security By Defaukt podcast. A CISSP-certified ethical hacker and government advisor, Carson is known for his practical insights on securing critical infrastructure and educating future cyber leaders.
Full Bio and articles